Ashton and Davidoff are two of the most refined Dominican premium brands. Both produce smooth, balanced cigars with elegant character. Both target enthusiasts who appreciate refinement over body. Different price tiers and brand positioning, but similar smoking philosophies. Most enthusiasts who appreciate Dominican refinement own boxes from both.
This comparison breaks down Ashton vs Davidoff side by side, what makes each different, and which brand fits which smoker.
Quick answer: Ashton and Davidoff are both Dominican premium brands making refined Connecticut-wrapped cigars. Ashton is more accessible ($9 to $19 per cigar); Davidoff is more luxury ($14 to $90). Both made in Dominican Republic. Ashton is owned by an American family; Davidoff is Swiss-owned. Both excellent for refined Dominican smoking. Ashton offers more value; Davidoff offers more luxury polish. Browse 200+ cigar brands to compare with other refined picks.
Brand histories
Ashton was founded in 1985 by Robert Levin, an American cigar industry veteran. The brand is produced in the Dominican Republic at the Tabacalera Fuente y Cia factory (the same facility that produces Arturo Fuente). Ashton has been continuously owned by the Levin family for four decades.
Davidoff was founded in 1924 by Zino Davidoff in Geneva, Switzerland. Originally focused on Cuban cigars, Davidoff transitioned to Dominican production in the 1980s. The brand is owned by the Oettinger Davidoff group.
For brand context, read the complete Ashton cigars brand guide and complete Davidoff cigars brand guide.
Side-by-side comparison
Flavor differences
Ashton Classic (mild Connecticut shade): Cream, cedar, light coffee, slight nutty notes. Very mild body.
Ashton VSG (full-body sun-grown): Cocoa, cedar, leather, complex pepper. Full body. Read Ashton VSG: the hardcore aficionado pick.
Davidoff Aniversario (medium Connecticut Ecuador): Cedar, cream, light coffee, balanced spice, smooth finish. Medium body.
Davidoff Royal Release (luxury Connecticut Ecuador): Refined Davidoff character with slightly fuller body and more complexity.
Ashton and Davidoff produce similar overall character (refined Dominican). The differences are in tier and intensity: Ashton VSG vs Davidoff Aniversario is closer comparison; Ashton Classic vs Davidoff Grand Cru is the entry comparison.
Top picks from each brand
Ashton top picks:
- Ashton Classic Robusto ($9 to $12). Reference mild Dominican.
- Ashton VSG Robusto ($11 to $14). Reference full-body Ashton. Read Ashton VSG complete guide.
- Ashton Heritage Puro Sol ($14 to $19). Boutique tier.
Davidoff top picks:
- Davidoff Grand Cru No. 1 ($14 to $20). Entry-luxury value.
- Davidoff Aniversario No. 2 ($35 to $48). Most popular Davidoff. Read Davidoff Aniversario line guide.
- Davidoff Royal Release ($60 to $90). Luxury reference.
Which brand fits which smoker
Choose Ashton if you...
- Want refined Dominican character at value pricing
- Like the Levin family's American cigar tradition
- Smoke daily and want consistent everyday cigars
- Want both mild (Classic) and full-body (VSG) options at similar pricing
Choose Davidoff if you...
- Want Swiss luxury positioning
- Pair with refined drinks (champagne, white wine, light coffee)
- Are smoking for special occasions
- Appreciate the brand prestige and packaging
For most enthusiasts, Ashton is the more accessible everyday brand and Davidoff is the special-occasion brand.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Ashton or Davidoff?
Both refined Dominican brands. Ashton is more accessible and family-owned. Davidoff is more luxury and Swiss-owned. Same overall flavor category at different price tiers.
Where are Ashton cigars made?
In the Dominican Republic at Tabacalera Fuente y Cia (the same facility that produces Arturo Fuente). Ashton uses Fuente facilities for production.
Where are Davidoff cigars made?
In the Dominican Republic at Davidoff's own facilities.
Which is more expensive?
Davidoff. Davidoff Aniversario ($30 to $55) is roughly twice the price of Ashton VSG ($11 to $14).
What's the most popular Ashton cigar?
Ashton Classic Robusto for value-premium and Ashton VSG Robusto for full-body. Both Cigar Aficionado-rated.
What's the most popular Davidoff cigar?
Davidoff Aniversario No. 2 (6 x 50 toro). Most popular Davidoff vitola.
Are both brands considered luxury?
Davidoff yes; Ashton is more accessible premium. Ashton VSG and Heritage are premium tier; Davidoff Aniversario and Royal Release are luxury tier.
Can I age both brands?
Yes. Both Connecticut-wrapped cigars age 2 to 5 years to additional flavor integration. The full-body Ashton VSG ages especially well.
Join the Deal-Hunting Community!
Share your cigar deals and steals with fellow enthusiasts:
- Cigar Deals & Steals Facebook Group
- Cigar Deals X Community
- r/EverythingCigars Deals & Steals
Explore More: Read the complete Ashton cigars brand guide, complete Davidoff cigars brand guide, Ashton VSG complete guide, and Davidoff Aniversario line guide. Compare with Padron vs Davidoff and Arturo Fuente vs Davidoff.
