Nat Sherman is one of the most storied names in American tobacco history — a brand that has represented New York sophistication and premium quality since 1930. While the legendary Nat Sherman Townhouse on 42nd Street may have closed its doors, the cigar brand continues to produce elegant, well-crafted cigars that carry on the legacy of Joel Sherman and his family's dedication to the art of tobacco.
This guide covers Nat Sherman's history, breaks down their major cigar lines, and helps you find the right Nat Sherman cigar for your palate.
The Nat Sherman Story
The Nat Sherman story begins in 1930 when Nat Sherman opened a small tobacco shop on Broadway in New York City. Sherman was a passionate tobacconist who believed that smoking should be an elegant, refined experience. His shop quickly became a destination for discerning New Yorkers, and Sherman's reputation for quality and personal service attracted celebrities, politicians, and tobacco enthusiasts from around the world.
Nat's son Joel Sherman took the reins in 1978 and elevated the brand further. Joel moved the flagship store to its iconic location at 12 East 42nd Street — the Nat Sherman Townhouse — which became one of the most famous tobacco retail destinations in the world. Under Joel's leadership, Nat Sherman expanded from primarily cigarettes and pipe tobacco into the premium cigar market.
Joel's approach to cigar making reflected the family's heritage: quality above all, with an emphasis on elegance and refinement rather than raw power. The brand partnered with experienced manufacturers in the Dominican Republic and Honduras to produce cigars that embodied the Nat Sherman philosophy — smooth, sophisticated, and consistently excellent.
The brand faced a significant change when the Townhouse closed in 2020, but the Nat Sherman cigar brand has continued under new ownership, maintaining the quality standards that Joel Sherman established.
Nat Sherman's Major Lines
Timeless Collection — The Flagship
The Timeless Collection is Nat Sherman's most acclaimed cigar line. These Dominican-made cigars feature carefully aged tobaccos and impeccable construction. The collection includes multiple wrapper options:
Timeless Prestige — An Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper with Dominican fillers. Mild-to-medium with cream, cedar, nuts, and gentle sweetness. An excellent beginner cigar.
Timeless Supreme — A Dominican Olor wrapper with richer, medium-bodied flavors of leather, cedar, and sweet spice. More complexity than the Prestige.
Timeless Nicaraguan — Features Nicaraguan tobaccos for a bolder, medium-to-full experience with earth, pepper, and cocoa. Showcases how Nicaraguan tobacco adds depth to the Timeless profile.
Timeless Sterling — A refined, medium-bodied blend with Ecuadorian wrapper and Dominican fillers. Cedar, cream, leather, and balanced spice. One of the brand's most elegant offerings.
Host Selection — Classic Hospitality
The Host Selection was originally created for the Nat Sherman Townhouse — cigars designed to be offered to guests as a mark of hospitality. Available in multiple wrapper options:
Host Hampton — Connecticut Shade wrapper. Mild and creamy with nuts and cedar. The lightest Host option.
Host Hobart — Maduro wrapper. Medium-bodied with chocolate, coffee, and sweet spice. Rich but balanced.
Host Hudson — Natural wrapper. Medium-bodied with leather, cedar, and pepper. Well-balanced and versatile.
Host Hunter — Cameroon wrapper. Medium-bodied with unique spicy-sweet notes and cedar. Distinctive character.
Epoca — Value and Quality
The Epoca line delivers Nat Sherman quality at a more accessible price point. Using Ecuadorian and Nicaraguan tobaccos, Epoca cigars offer medium-bodied flavors of earth, cedar, and gentle spice. They are solid everyday smokes that maintain the brand's reputation for construction and consistency. Good value picks.
Metropolitan Selection — Bold and Complex
The Metropolitan Selection represents Nat Sherman's fuller-bodied offerings. Using select Dominican and Nicaraguan tobaccos with premium wrappers, these medium-to-full cigars deliver richer flavors of leather, dark chocolate, spice, and sweet cedar. The Metropolitan Maduro variant adds a dark wrapper for even deeper chocolate and coffee notes. A great step up for smokers who enjoy the brand's refinement but want more intensity.
Other Notable Lines
Nat Sherman 1930 — Celebrating the brand's founding year. A medium-bodied Dominican blend with aged tobaccos, delivering cedar, cream, leather, and gentle sweetness.
Nat Sherman Point Fives — A small-format cigar designed for a quick 20-minute smoke. Available in multiple wrappers, these deliver surprising flavor and complexity in a compact package. Learn about cigar sizes.
Nat Sherman Benchmark — A fuller-bodied Honduran blend with earth, pepper, and dark chocolate. One of Nat Sherman's boldest offerings.
Where to Buy Nat Sherman Cigars
Browse and compare Nat Sherman pricing across multiple trusted retailers on the Nat Sherman brand page at Cigar Finder. For the full catalog with real-time pricing, visit CigarFinder's premium cigars page and filter by brand.
New to buying online? Read our guide on how to buy cigars online safely. Looking for deals? Check our coupon codes page and best cigar deals guide.
Join the Deal-Hunting Community! Share your cigar deals and steals with fellow enthusiasts: - Cigar Deals & Steals Facebook Group - Cigar Deals X Community - r/EverythingCigars Deals & Steals
Explore More: Visit our Nat Sherman brand page to compare prices. Great for beginners — see our beginner's guide. Browse all premium cigars.
