Cigars are more than just rolled tobacco; they represent luxury, tradition, and the art of relaxation. Whether you’re a seasoned smoker or just getting started, one question always stands out: What makes a cigar the best?
Some cigars are masterpieces, carefully crafted and earning praise from experts for their complex flavors and flawless construction. Others capture the hearts of everyday smokers, becoming top sellers thanks to their accessibility and affordability.
👉 Want to start with beginner favorites? Explore our Best Cigars for First-Time Smokers.
But what truly sets these two categories apart? And can a cigar be both?
Whether you’re drawn to the intricate flavors of top-rated cigars or the reliability of best-sellers, finding the right cigar can be an exciting journey. CigarFinder.com is a great resource to help you explore and discover the best cigars to match your preferences.
Let’s take a closer look at the world of cigars, comparing the top-rated selections praised by aficionados with the best-selling cigars loved by the masses.
What Makes a Cigar Top-Rated?
A top-rated cigar is more than just tobacco wrapped in a leaf, it’s a work of art. These cigars offer an experience, a story told through the aroma, flavor, and craftsmanship. From the first glance at the silky wrapper to the complex flavors that emerge with every puff, everything about a top-rated cigar is deliberate.
Picture opening a box of premium cigars. The earthy aroma of aged tobacco fills the air. The wrapper feels smooth under your fingertips. As you take the first draw, notes of cocoa, leather, and roasted coffee unfold, leaving a lasting impression. This is what separates a top-rated cigar from the rest.
These cigars often use rare, aged tobaccos and are hand-rolled by skilled artisans. They’re not mass-produced, and their quality reflects that exclusivity.
Comparison Table: Top-Rated Cigars vs. Top-Selling Cigars
Want more beginner-friendly picks? Check out our Best Cigars for First-Time Smokers.
Top 10 Rated Cigars in the USA
Padron 1964 Anniversary Series Maduro
- Profile: Full-bodied
- Wrapper: Maduro
- Flavors: Cocoa, coffee, earth
- Why It’s a Favorite: A luxurious cigar with exceptional depth of flavor, perfectly balanced with a smooth draw.
- Find this cigar at CigarFinder.
Arturo Fuente Opus X
- Profile: Full-bodied
- Wrapper: Dominican Sun Grown
- Flavors: Spice, cedar, cocoa
- Why It’s a Favorite: Bold, complex, and legendary, this cigar sets the standard for premium smokes.
- Explore more at CigarFinder.
Liga Privada No. 9
- Profile: Full-bodied
- Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro
- Flavors: Espresso, chocolate, pepper
- Why It’s a Favorite: Known for its rich, chocolatey finish and flawless construction.
Davidoff Winston Churchill The Late Hour
- Profile: Medium-full-bodied
- Wrapper: Ecuadorian Habano
- Flavors: Dark chocolate, leather, wood
- Why It’s a Favorite: A refined cigar with luxurious, smoky richness, perfect for special occasions.
My Father Le Bijou 1922
- Profile: Full-bodied
- Wrapper: Oscuro
- Flavors: Pepper, citrus, cedar
- Why It’s a Favorite: Bold, adventurous, and full of character, a must-try for seasoned smokers.
Oliva Serie V Melanio
- Profile: Medium-full-bodied
- Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sumatra
- Flavors: Sweet spice, cocoa, coffee
- Why It’s a Favorite: A smooth yet flavorful cigar with an award-winning reputation.
Olmec Claro Corona
- Profile: Medium-full-bodied
- Wrapper: Mexican Claro
- Flavors: Creamy cedar, light spices, subtle sweetness
- Why It’s a Favorite: This boutique cigar is celebrated for its smooth, balanced flavor and refined construction.
Ashton VSG Sun Grown
- Profile: Full-bodied
- Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sun Grown
- Flavors: Leather, roasted coffee, cedar
- Why It’s a Favorite: Renowned for its bold, rich flavor and impeccable craftsmanship.
E.P. Carrillo Allegiance Confidant
- Profile: Medium-full-bodied
- Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sumatra
- Flavors: Earth, cocoa, dark fruit
- Why It’s a Favorite: This cigar is admired for its complexity, offering a perfect balance of boldness and smoothness.
El Pulpo Belicoso Grande
- Profile: Full-bodied
- Wrapper: Mexican San Andrés
- Flavors: Dark chocolate, espresso, pepper
- Why It’s a Favorite: This unique blend delivers a bold, satisfying smoking experience with a rich finish.
Top 10 Selling Cigars in the USA
Macanudo Café Hyde Park
- Profile: Mild-bodied
- Why It’s a Favorite: A creamy, approachable cigar that’s perfect for beginners.
- Shop Macanudo Café here.
Romeo y Julieta 1875
- Profile: Medium-bodied
- Why It’s a Favorite: A classic cigar with a balanced flavor profile, ideal for everyday smoking.
- View Cigars Here
Acid Kuba Kuba
- Profile: Mild-medium
- Why It’s a Favorite: Sweet and aromatic, with hints of honey and herbs, making it a standout in the infused category.
Montecristo White Series
- Profile: Mild-medium
- Why It’s a Favorite: Smooth, creamy, and versatile, a crowd-pleaser for all levels of smokers.
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
- Profile: Medium-bodied
- Why It’s a Favorite: A quick yet satisfying smoke with earthy cedar notes.
Punch Gran Puro
- Profile: Full-bodied
- Why It’s a Favorite: Bold, rich, and affordable, with strong coffee and spice flavors.
Cohiba Black
- Profile: Full-bodied
- Why It’s a Favorite: A luxurious cigar with dark chocolate undertones, offering a rich experience.
CAO Flavours Moontrance
- Profile: Mild
- Why It’s a Favorite: Sweet vanilla and bourbon notes make it a favorite among casual smokers.
Oliva Serie G
- Profile: Medium-bodied
- Why It’s a Favorite: Consistent and flavorful, with a nutty, slightly sweet profile.
Perdomo Lot 23 Connecticut
- Profile: Mild-medium
- Why It’s a Favorite: Creamy and smooth, with a touch of spice, making it perfect for any time of day.
FAQs
Q: What’s the best way to explore both top-rated and top-selling cigars?
A: Consider trying a sampler pack or browsing a resource like CigarFinder.com to compare options and find the right cigar for you.
Final Thoughts
Cigars are as diverse as the people who enjoy them. Whether you’re drawn to the artistry of a top-rated cigar or the reliability of a top-seller, the best cigar is the one that fits your taste and occasion. Ready to find your next cigar? Visit CigarFinder.com to explore a wide selection of top-rated and best-selling cigars. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned smoker, you’ll find something to love. After all, cigars are more than just smoke, they’re an experience to savor.
💨 Not sure where to start?
Try a Sampler Pack and explore both top-rated and top-selling cigars in one go.
